Review Article| Volume 21, ISSUE 12, P1852-1861.e8, December 2020

Download started.


Role of a Clinical Ethics Committee in Residential Aged Long-Term Care Settings: A Systematic Review



      To conduct a systematic review of literature examining the establishment and operation of clinical ethical committees (CECs) in long-term care (LTC).


      Systematic review.

      Setting and Participants

      LTC recipients/family or staff.


      Five databases (Ovid Medline, Ovid Cochrane Library, Ovid PsycINFO, Ovid EMBASE, and CINAHL via EbscoHost) were systematically searched from their inception to May 8, 2020. The initial search was conducted on August 22, 2017, and updated on May 8, 2020, to identify peer-reviewed studies, commentaries, or editorials. The quality of studies was assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool.


      Thirty-three articles were identified for inclusion, of which 13 were primary studies. Most articles were set in the United States. The purpose of establishing a CEC in LTC was typically to assist in dealing with ethical issues and improve the quality of care. The articles described the roles of CECs to include prospective case consultation, case review, policy development, and ethics education. Articles rarely reported whether the CEC was required by or enshrined in law. Membership of CECs was between 4 and 20 members and most commonly included nursing staff, physicians, and directors/administrators. The rationale behind the membership was rarely described. For case consultation, articles described that CECs were typically convened upon referral. The resident issues which a CEC could address included end-of-life care decisions, autonomy/self-determination, and medical treatment decisions. The staff issues addressed by CECs included medical treatment decisions, end-of-life care decisions, and decision-making issues. The decision-making process followed by CECs varied. The outcome of a CEC meeting was typically a recommendation, whereas the implementation of CEC recommendations and decisions were rarely reported.

      Conclusions and Implications

      This systematic review identifies how CECs operate in the LTC setting. CECs have the potential to provide valuable support in addressing complex ethical issues in LTC; however, empirical research is required to determine their efficacy in the LTC setting.


      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'


      Subscribe to Journal of the American Medical Directors Association
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect


        • MacLeod S.
        • Schwebke K.
        • Hawkin K.
        • et al.
        Need for comprehensive health care quality measures for older adults.
        Popul Health Manag. 2018; 21: 296-302
        • National Research Council (US)
        The Health of Aging Populations.
        in: Preparing for an Aging World: The Case for Cross-National Research. National Academies Press (US), Washington (DC)2001
        • Perni S.
        Moral distress: A call to action.
        AMA J Ethics. 2017; 19: 533-536
        • Smith D.
        • Bugeja L.
        • Cunningham N.
        • et al.
        A Systematic review of sexual assaults in nursing homes.
        Gerontologist. 2018; 58: e369-e383
        • Rosen T.
        • Lachs M.S.
        • Pillemer K.
        Sexual aggression between residents in nursing homes: Literature synthesis of an underrecognized Problem.
        J Am Geriatri Soc. 2010; 58: 1970-1979
        • Payne B.K.
        • Gainey R.R.
        The criminal justice response to elder abuse in nursing homes: A routine activities perspective.
        West Crim Rev. 2006; 7: 67-81
        • Bellenger E.
        • Ibrahim J.E.
        • Bugeja L.
        • et al.
        Physical restraint deaths in a 13-year national cohort of nursing home residents.
        Age Ageing. 2017; 46: 688-693
        • Maker Y.
        • McSherry B.
        Regulating restraint use in mental health and aged care settings: Lessons from the Oakden scandal.
        Alternative Law Journal. 2019; 44: 29-36
        • Mann E.
        • Köpke S.
        • Haastert B.
        • et al.
        Psychotropic medication use among nursing home residents in Austria: A cross-sectional study.
        BMC Geriatr. 2009; 9: 18
      1. American Geriatrics Society Expert Panel on the Care of Older Adults with Multimorbidity, Guiding principles for the care of older adults with multimorbidity: An approach for clinicians: American Geriatrics Society Expert Panel on the Care of Older Adults with Multimorbidity.
        J Am Geriatr Soc. 2012; 60: e1-e25
        • Buckley J.S.
        • Salpeter S.R.
        A risk-benefit assessment of dementia medications: Systematic review of the evidence.
        Drugs Aging. 2015; 32: 453-467
        • Holmes A.L.
        • Bugeja L.
        • Young C.
        • et al.
        Deaths due to thermal injury from cigarette smoking in a 13-year national cohort of nursing home residents.
        Int J Older People Nurs. 2019; 14: e12233
        • Ibrahim J.E.
        • Davis M.C.
        Impediments to applying the ‘dignity of risk’ principle in residential aged care services.
        Australas J Ageing. 2013; 32: 188-193
        • Silvester W.
        • Fullam R.S.
        • Parslow R.A.
        • et al.
        Quality of advance care planning policy and practice in residential aged care facilities in Australia.
        BMJ Support Palliat Care. 2013; 3: 349
        • Peel N.M.
        Epidemiology of falls in older sge.
        Can J Aging. 2011; 30: 7-19
        • Rubenstein L.Z.
        Falls in older people: Epidemiology, risk factors and strategies for prevention.
        Age Ageing. 2006; 35: ii37-ii41
        • Gibson R.E.
        • Harden M.
        • Byles J.
        • et al.
        Incidence of falls and fall-related outcomes among people in aged-care facilities in the Lower Hunter region, NSW.
        NSW Public Health Bull. 2008; 19: 166
        • Vossius C.
        • Selbaek G.
        • Benth J.S.
        • et al.
        Mortality in nursing home residents: A longitudinal study over three years.
        PLoS ONE. 2018; 13: e0203480
        • Mavromaras K.
        • Knight G.
        • Isherwood L.
        • et al.
        The Aged Care Workforce, 2016. Canberra: Department of Health. 2017.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety
        Interim Report: Neglect (Volume 2, Hearing Overviews and Case Studies). Australia: Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety. 2019.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety
        Interim Report: Neglect (Volume 1). Australia: Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety. 2019.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Australian Law Reform Commission
        Elder Abuse - A National Legal Response (Final Report). Sydney: Australian Law Reform Commission. 2017.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Australian Government
        Quality of Care Principles 2014 (Cth).
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Singer P.A.
        • Pellegrino E.D.
        • Siegler M.
        Clinical ethics revisited.
        BMC Med Ethics. 2001; 2: 1
        • Newson A.J.
        The value of clinical ethics support in Australian health care.
        Med J Aust. 2015; 202: 568-569
        • Miles A.
        • Watt T.
        • Wong W.-Y.
        • et al.
        Complex feeding decisions: Perceptions of staff, patients, and their families in the inpatient hospital setting.
        Gerontol Geriatr Med. 2016; (Jan-Dec:e-collection)
        • Kenny B.
        Food culture, preferences and ethics in dysphagia management.
        Bioethics. 2015; 29: 646-652
        • Johnson S.
        • Ostaszkiewicz J.
        • O' Connell B.
        Moving beyond resistance to restraint minimization: A case study of change management in aged Care.
        Worldviews Evid Based Nurs. 2009; 6: 210-218
        • Nay R.
        • Koch S.
        Overcoming restraint use: Examining barriers in Australian ages care facilities.
        J Gerontol Nurs. 2006; 32: 33-38
        • Moher D.
        • Liberati A.
        • Tetzlaff J.
        • et al.
        Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement.
        Ann Intern Med. 2009; 151: 264-269
        • Thomson Reuters
        EndNote X7. New York: Thomson Reuters. 2014.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Veritas Health Innovation
        Covidence systematic review software. Melbourne, Australia.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Hong Q.N.
        • Pluye P.
        • Fàbregues S.
        • et al.
        Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) Version 2018. Canada: McGill University. 2018.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Anonymous
        Program clarifies ethical issues in care of the dying patient.
        Health Prog. 1984; 65: 16-18
        • Beckel J.
        Resolving ethical problems in long-term care.
        J Gerontol Nurs. 1996; 22: 20-26
        • Besdine R.W.
        Decisions to withhold treatment from nursing home residents.
        J Am Geriatr Soc. 1983; 31: 602-606
        • Buss D.D.
        Choices: The ethics of dying pose new challenges for caregivers.
        Contemp Longterm Care. 1994; 17: 40-47
        • Chichin E.R.
        • Olson E.
        An ethics consult team in geriatric long-term care.
        Camb Q Healthc Ethics. 1995; 4: 178-184
        • Crawford K.F.
        How ethical dilemmas are resolved.
        J Long Term Care Adm. 1994; 22: 25-28
        • Drane J.F.
        The Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA) and the incapacitated patient: Policy suggestions for healthcare ethics committees.
        HEC forum. 1991; 3: 309-320
        • Ejaz F.K.
        Predictors of advance directives in institutionalized elderly.
        J Gerontol Soc Work. 2000; 33: 67-89
        • Gillick M.R.
        Medical decision-making for the unbefriended nursing home resident.
        J Ethics Law Aging. 1995; 1: 87-92
        • Glasser G.
        • Zweibel N.
        • Cassel C.
        The ethics committee in the nursing home: Results of a national survey.
        J Am Geriatr Soc. 1988; 36: 150-156
        • Hogstel M.O.
        • Curry L.C.
        • Walker C.A.
        • et al.
        Ethics committees in long-term care facilities.
        Geriatric Nurs (Minneap). 2004; 25: 364-369
        • Kapp M.B.
        Medical decision-making for older adults in institutional settings: Is beneficience dead in an age of risk management?.
        Issues Law Med. 1995; 11: 29-46
        • Kaufmann A.
        Long-Term Care Coalition of the Orange County Bioethics Network (California).
        HEC Forum. 1994; 6: 183
        • Kelly C.
        • Lazaroff A.
        Learning to pay attention: An ethics study group refocuses on issues affecting long-term care residents' daily lives.
        Health Prog. 1993; 74: 40-43
        • Libow L.
        Ethics rounds at the nursing home: An alternative to an ethics committee.
        J Am Geriatr Soc. 1992; 40: 95-97
        • Levenson S.A.
        • Feinsod F.M.
        Implementing effective ethics decision-making programs.
        Ann Longterm Care. 1999; 7: 232-237
        • Miles S.H.
        • Gomez C.F.
        • Zweibel N.R.
        • et al.
        Nursing home policies addressing the use or withdrawal of life-sustaining medical treatments.
        Clin Geriatr Med. 1988; 4: 681-690
        • Mezey M.
        • Mitty E.
        • Rappaport M.
        • et al.
        Implementation of the Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA) in nursing homes in New York City.
        J Am Geriatr Soc. 1997; 45: 43-49
        • Nichols J.
        When there is no ethics committee.
        Caring Ages. 2008; 9: 13
        • Nusbaum N.J.
        Feeding tubes: Ethical decision making in theory and in practice.
        Ann Longterm Care. 2001; 9: 20
        • Olson E.
        • Chichin E.
        • Meyers H.
        • et al.
        Early Experiences of an Ethics Consult Team.
        J Am Geriatr Soc. 1994; 42: 437-441
        • Olson E.
        Ethical issues in the nursing home.
        Mt Sinai J Med. 1993; 60: 555-559
        • Price D.M.
        • Armstrong P.W.
        New Jersey's "Granny Doe" squad: Arguments about mechanisms for protection of vulnerable patients.
        Law Med Health Care. 1989; 17: 255
        • Sansone P.
        The evolution of a long-term care ethics committee.
        HEC Forum. 1996; 8: 44-51
        • Weston C.M.
        • O’Brien L.A.
        • Goldfarb N.I.
        • et al.
        The NJ SEED project: Evaluation of an innovative initiative for ethics training in nursing homes.
        J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2005; 6: 68-75
        • Whiteneck M.R.
        Integrating ethics with quality assurance in long term care.
        QRB Qual Rev Bull. 1988; 14: 138-143
        • Zuckerman C.
        Clinical ethics in geriatric care settings.
        Generations. 1994; 18: 9-12
        • Hillman J.
        Sexual Consent capacity: Ethical issues and challenges in long-term care.
        Clin Gerontol. 2017; 40: 43-50
        • Lemiengre J.
        • Dierckx de Casterle B.
        • Denier Y.
        • et al.
        Content analysis of euthanasia policies of nursing homes in Flanders (Belgium).
        Med Health Care Philos. 2009; 12: 313-322
        • Lemiengre J.
        • Dierckx de Casterlé B.
        • Verbeke G.
        • et al.
        Ethics policies on euthanasia in nursing homes: A survey in Flanders, Belgium.
        Soc Sci Med. 2008; 66: 376-386
        • Gordon M.
        • Turner L.
        • Bourret E.
        Addressing ethical issues in geriatrics and long-term care: Ethics education at the Baycrest Centre for Geriatric Care.
        Med Law. 2000; 19: 475
        • Bollig G.
        • Schmidt G.
        • Rosland J.H.
        • et al.
        Ethical challenges in nursing homes–staff's opinions and experiences with systematic ethics meetings with participation of residents' relatives.
        Scand J Caring Sci. 2015; 29: 810-823
        • Janssens R.M.
        • van Zadelhoff E.
        • van Loo G.
        • et al.
        Evaluation and perceived results of moral case deliberation: A mixed methods study.
        Nurs Ethics. 2015; 22: 870-880
        • Australian Health Ethics Committee (AHEC) of the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC)
        AHEC consensus statement on clinical ethics. Australia: NHMRC. 2015.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Harris-Kojetin L.
        • Sengupta M.
        • Lendon J.
        • et al.
        Long-term care providers and services users in the United States 2015–16. Vital Health Statistics. USA: National Center for Health Statistics. 2019.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Competition and Markets Authority
        Care homes market study (final report). London: Competition and Markets Authority. 2017.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Department of Health
        2017-18 Report on the Operation of the Aged Care Act 1997. Canberra: Department of Health. 2018.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Dyer S.M.
        • Gnanamanickam E.S.
        • Liu E.
        • et al.
        Diagnosis of dementia in residential aged care settings in Australia: An opportunity for improvements in quality of care?.
        Australas J Ageing. 2018; 37: e155-e158
        • Björk S.
        • Juthberg C.
        • Lindkvist M.
        • et al.
        Exploring the prevalence and variance of cognitive impairment, pain, neuropsychiatric symptoms and ADL dependency among persons living in nursing homes: A cross-sectional study.
        BMC Geriatr. 2016; 16: 154
        • Zimmerman S.
        • Sloane P.D.
        • Reed D.
        Dementia prevalence and care in assisted living.
        Health Aff. 2014; 33: 658-666
        • World Health Organization
        Research ethics committees: Basic concepts for capacity-building. Switzerland: World Health Organization. 2009.
        (Available at:) (Accessed January 25, 2020)
        • Shaw D.
        • Elger B.
        Putting patients on research ethics committees.
        J R Soc Med. 2014; 107: 304-307
        • McLean S.A.M.
        What and who are clinical ethics committees for?.
        J Med Ethics. 2007; 33: 497-500
        • Gagnon E.
        • Clément M.
        • Bordeleau L.
        Speaking out and being heard residents’ committees in Quebec’s residential long-term care centre.
        Health Care Anal. 2017; 25: 308-322
        • Evans J.M.
        The changing ethics of health care.
        Caring Ages. 2016; 17: 12
        • Calman K.C.
        Evolutionary ethics: Can values change.
        J Med Ethics. 2004; 30: 366
        • Gillon R.
        Clinical ethics committees–Pros and cons.
        J Med Ethics. 1997; 23: 203-204
        • Altisent R.
        • Martín-Espildora N.
        • Delgado-Marroquín M.T.
        Health care ethics consultation. Individual consultant or committee model?: Pros and cons.
        Am J Bioeth. 2013; 13: 25-27
        • Ibrahim J.E.
        • Macphail A.
        • Winbolt M.
        • et al.
        Limitation of care orders in patients with a diagnosis of dementia.
        Resuscitation. 2016; 98: 118-124
        • Wilkins J.M.
        More than capacity: Alternatives for sexual decision making for individuals with dementia.
        Gerontologist. 2015; 55: 716-723
        • Holmes A.
        • Bugeja L.
        • Ranson D.
        • et al.
        The potential for inadvertent adverse consequences of open disclosure in Australia: When good intentions cause further harm.
        Med Sci Law. 2019; 59: 265-274