If you don't remember your password, you can reset it by entering your email address and clicking the Reset Password button. You will then receive an email that contains a secure link for resetting your password
If the address matches a valid account an email will be sent to __email__ with instructions for resetting your password
Address correspondence to Christine D. Jones, MD, MS, Division of Hospital Medicine, Department of Medicine, University of Colorado, Anschutz Medical Campus, Mail Stop F782, 12401 East 17th Avenue, Aurora, Colorado 80045, USA.
Adult and Child Consortium for Health Outcomes Research and Delivery Science (ACCORDS), University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora, CO, USA
Adult and Child Consortium for Health Outcomes Research and Delivery Science (ACCORDS), University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora, CO, USA
Data Science to Patient Value Program, ACCORDS, University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora, CO, USA
Division of Health Care Policy and Research, Department of Medicine, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, CO, USA
Adults discharged from the hospital with skilled home health care (HHC) are at high risk for preventable adverse events, including medication errors and hospital readmissions.
High prevalence of medication discrepancies between home health referrals and Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services home health certification and plan of care and their potential to affect safety of vulnerable elderly adults.
HIEs are designed to allow clinicians in different care settings to access a patient's medical information electronically, and have potential to improve information exchange between hospitals and other care settings.
The association between HIE participation during hospital to home health agency transitions and hospital readmissions has not previously been examined. Therefore, we completed a secondary data analysis using the statewide Colorado all payer claims database (COAPCD) to examine if hospital and/or home health agency participation in a regional HIE is associated with reductions in 30-day readmissions.
The study sample included Medicare and Medicare Advantage (MA) beneficiaries hospitalized in Colorado between January 1, 2014, and August 31, 2018. The primary outcome was 30-day hospital readmission and the primary independent variables were HIE participation by the hospital and/or home health agency for each hospital to HHC transition. In multivariable generalized linear regression, additional patient, hospital, and home health agency characteristics that might influence the association between readmissions and HIE participation were included in the model.
After exclusions (see Supplementary Figure 1), this analysis included 46,903 individuals with 54,016 hospital to home health transitions. Patients were 75 years old (median), 57.8% were female, 82.8% had Medicare, and 17.2% had MA insurance (see Supplementary Table 1). The overall 30-day readmission rate was 12.8%. Table 1 shows patient, hospital, and home health agency characteristics by 30-day readmissions. Hospital HIE participation [odds ratio (OR) 0.84, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.79–0.89] but not home health agency HIE participation (OR 1.02, 95% CI 0.97–1.07) was associated with lower odds of 30-day readmissions in unadjusted models. After adjusting for multiple covariates, neither hospital nor home health agency HIE participation was associated with lower 30-day readmissions (adjusted hospital OR 0.94, 95% CI 0.87–1.02; adjusted home health agency OR 0.99, 95% CI 0.93–1.05).
Table 1Patient, Hospital. and Home Health Agency Characteristics by 30-day Readmission (Row Percentages)
Variable
Total n = 54,016
30-Day Readmission
P Value
No n = 47,116
Yes n = 6900
Patient characteristics
Age, median (IQR)
75.0 (68.0–83.0)
75.0 (68.0–83.0)
76.0 (69.0–84.0)
<.001
Length of stay, median (IQR)
3.0 (2.0–5.0)
3.0 (2.0–5.0)
4.0 (2.0–6.0)
<.001
Sex
<.001
Female
57.8 (30,981)
87.7 (27,177)
12.3 (3804)
Male
42.2 (22,604)
86.6 (19,570)
13.4 (3034)
Payer
.828
Medicare
82.8 (44,750)
87.2 (39,040)
12.8 (5710)
Medicare Advantage
17.2 (9266)
87.2 (8076)
12.8 (1190)
Charlson Comorbidity Index score
<.001
0
30.1 (16,265)
92.9 (15,107)
7.1 (1158)
1
25.1 (13,579)
88.8 (12,054)
11.2 (1525)
2
17.1 (9217)
85.3 (7860)
14.7 (1357)
3+
27.7 (14,955)
80.9 (12,095)
19.1 (2860)
Primary diagnoses for hospitalization
Acute myocardial infarction
.002
Yes
1.5 (793)
83.6 (663)
16.4 (130)
No
98.5 (53,223)
87.3 (46,453)
12.7 (6770)
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
<.001
Yes
1.8 (994)
83.5 (830)
16.5 (164)
No
98.2 (53,022)
87.3 (46,286)
12.7 (6736)
Pneumonia
.004
Yes
2.8 (1498)
84.8 (1270)
15.2 (228)
No
97.2 (52,518)
87.3 (45,846)
12.7 (6672)
Stroke
.004
Yes
2.1 (1108)
90.1 (998)
9.9 (110)
No
97.9 (52,908)
87.2 (46,118)
12.8 (6790)
Heart failure
<.001
Yes
2.6 (1381)
80.1 (1106)
19.9 (275)
No
97.4 (52,635)
87.4 (46,010)
12.6 (6625)
Total hip or knee arthroplasty
<.001
Yes
21.9 (11,807)
96.0 (11,336)
4.0 (471)
No
78.1 (42,209)
84.8 (35,780)
15.2 (6429)
Hospital characteristics
Hospital type
<.001
Acute care hospitals
98.4 (53,141)
87.2 (46,316)
12.8 (6825)
Critical access hospitals
1.6 (875)
91.4 (800)
8.6 (75)
Hospital compare quality star rating
<.001
2
3.2 (1701)
83.4 (1418)
16.6 (283)
3
39.7 (21,129)
86.4 (18,246)
13.6 (2883)
4
46.9 (24,979)
87.6 (21,874)
12.4 (3105)
5
10.2 (5432)
89.1 (4840)
10.9 (592)
Discharges from hospital (total in cohort)
<.001
0–139
1.6 (862)
89.9 (775)
10.1 (87)
140–616
8.4 (4542)
89.3 (4057)
10.7 (485)
617–1622
28.4 (15,343)
86.2 (13,231)
13.8 (2112)
>1622
61.6 (33,269)
87.3 (29,053)
12.7 (4216)
Ownership - Hospital
<.001
Government
15.7 (8474)
85.8 (7269)
14.2 (1205)
Nonprofit
68.5 (37,016)
87.2 (32,273)
12.8 (4743)
Proprietary
15.8 (8526)
88.8 (7574)
11.2 (952)
Hospital - HIE use at discharge
<.001
Yes
80.1 (43,292)
87.6 (37,935)
12.4 (5357)
No
19.9 (10,724)
85.6 (9181)
14.4 (1543)
Home health agency characteristics
Home health agency location
<.001
Rural
11.4 (6183)
88.9 (5494)
11.1 (689)
Urban
88.6 (47,833)
87.0 (41,622)
13.0 (6211)
Home health compare quality star rating
.002
≤ 2.5
7.3 (3938)
86.0 (3388)
14.0 (550)
3
13.4 (7193)
88.1 (6334)
11.9 (859)
3.5
19.1 (10,222)
87.8 (8971)
12.2 (1251)
4
28.6 (15,325)
87.2 (13,367)
12.8 (1958)
4.5
23.7 (12,693)
86.5 (10,981)
13.5 (1712)
5
7.9 (4213)
87.6 (3691)
12.4 (522)
Number of referrals to home health agencies (total in cohort)
<.001
0–92
2.7 (1444)
84.3 (1217)
15.7 (227)
93–212
7.8 (4236)
86.4 (3658)
13.6 (578)
213–471
17.5 (9439)
86.7 (8185)
13.3 (1254)
>471
72.0 (38,897)
87.6 (34,056)
12.4 (4841)
Ownership – Home Health Agencies
<.001
Government
2.3 (1253)
87.5 (1097)
12.5 (156)
Nonprofit
40.3 (21,580)
86.6 (18,678)
13.4 (2902)
Proprietary
57.4 (30,751)
87.7 (26,957)
12.3 (3794)
Home health agency – all services offered
.431
No
4.1 (2214)
87.8 (1943)
12.2 (271)
Yes
95.9 (51,370)
87.2 (44,789)
12.8 (6581)
Home health agency - HIE use at discharge
.450
No
43.9 (23,697)
87.3 (20,699)
12.7 (2998)
Yes
56.1 (30,319)
87.1 (26,417)
12.9 (3902)
Cells are % (n) by row, or median [interquartile range (IQR)]; P values from Pearson's χ2 test or the Wilcoxon Rank Sum test.
These findings should be interpreted in the broader context of care transition interventions, in which multiple systematic reviews have identified that transitions of care interventions are more likely to reduce readmissions when they include multiple components.
For example, in a systematic review with a meta-analysis of 42 studies, care transition interventions that were composed of 5 or more unique components had a lower readmission risk compared with control groups (OR 0.63, 95% CI 0.53–0.76). In this review, examples of unique components included telephone follow-up, home visits, timely communication with the primary care provider, and timely postdischarge follow-up. As a result, it might be reasonable to conclude that although HIE participation may not alone reduce 30-day readmissions, HIE participation could support other components of a care transitions program to ultimately reduce readmissions.
This analysis has multiple limitations. First, the observational nature of this study does not fully account for the self-selection of hospitals and home health agency participation in the HIE. Although we used multivariable regression to include variables that could influence the association between HIE participation and readmissions, given the complexity of information exchange and care transitions, it is likely that unmeasured confounders influenced our findings, such as actual use of the HIE for individual patients. In addition, although the COAPCD has multiple strengths, including the ability to follow individuals longitudinally across settings and payers, it lacks comprehensive race and ethnicity data, as well as home health assessment and functional data that could have enhanced this analysis and the interpretation of findings. Finally, this analysis did not capture use of information exchange mechanisms outside of HIE, such as direct access to hospital electronic health records for home health agencies, which may represent an important and unmeasured variable given the increasing use of these as supplements or alternatives to HIEs for information exchange.
In sum, although HIEs are increasingly available to promote better coordination across care settings, HIE participation for hospitals and/or home health agencies was not significantly associated with reductions in 30-day readmissions when included in a full regression model. Future work to understand how best to implement and integrate the HIE into HHC workflow could provide important insights to optimize HIE use. In addition, because multiple components are frequently included in successful care transitions initiatives, future work could aim to understand how HIE use by hospitals and/or home health could be combined with other components of transitional care (eg, HHC frontloading, primary care follow-up) to improve outcomes beyond readmissions (eg, functional outcomes, patient quality of life) for patients as they transition from the hospital to HHC.
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge the Colorado Regional Health Information Organization for providing key data about hospital and home health agency HIE participation.
The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the University of Colorado School of Medicine, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, the Colorado Department of Health Care Policy and Financing, the Center for Improving Value in Health Care or the Colorado Regional Health Information Organization.
Supplementary Data
Supplementary Table 1Patient, Hospital, and Home Health Agency Characteristics by Health Information Exchange Participation
Variable
Total n = 54,016
Hospital+/HHA+ n = 25,817
Hospital+/HHA− n = 17,475
Hospital−/HHA+ n = 4502
Hospital−/HHA− n = 6222
P Value
Patient characteristics
Age, median (IQR)
75.0 (68.0–83.0)
75.0 (69.0–83.0)
75.0 (69.0–83.0)
73.0 (67.0–81.0)
75.0 (68.0–82.0)
<.001
Length of stay, median (IQR)
3.0 (2.0–5.0)
3.0 (2.0–5.0)
3.0 (2.0–5.0)
3.0 (2.0–6.0)
3.0 (2.0–6.0)
<.001
Female
57.8 (30,981)
58.1 (14,908)
57.6 (9941)
56.5 (2531)
58.4 (3601)
.156
Payer
<.001
Medicare
82.8 (44,750)
85.9 (22,181)
74.5 (13,021)
92.3 (4156)
86.7 (5392)
Medicare Advantage
17.2 (9266)
14.1 (3636)
25.5 (4454)
7.7 (346)
13.3 (830)
Charlson Comorbidity Index Score
<.001
0
30.1 (16,265)
30.8 (7953)
30.2 (5273)
26.9 (1210)
29.4 (1829)
1
25.1 (13,579)
25.8 (6655)
24.7 (4309)
23.7 (1068)
24.9 (1547)
2
17.1 (9217)
16.8 (4336)
17.3 (3023)
17.1 (771)
17.5 (1087)
3+
27.7 (14,955)
26.6 (6873)
27.9 (4870)
32.3 (1453)
28.3 (1759)
Primary diagnoses for hospitalization
Acute myocardial infarction
1.5 (793)
1.4 (367)
1.6 (281)
1.2 (56)
1.4 (89)
.224
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
1.8 (994)
2.1 (537)
1.5 (261)
1.6 (74)
2.0 (122)
<.001
Pneumonia
2.8 (1498)
2.9 (749)
2.6 (457)
2.3 (102)
3.1 (190)
.026
Stroke
2.1 (1108)
2.1 (549)
1.9 (339)
1.8 (82)
2.2 (138)
.278
Heart failure
2.6 (1381)
2.7 (691)
2.2 (384)
2.9 (129)
2.8 (177)
.002
Total hip or knee arthroplasty
21.9 (11,807)
22.3 (5768)
22.7 (3965)
19.8 (890)
19.0 (1184)
<.001
Hospital characteristics
Hospital type
<.001
Acute care hospitals
98.4 (53,141)
99.5 (25,677)
100.0 (17,472)
97.7 (4397)
89.9 (5595)
Critical access hospitals
1.6 (875)
0.5 (140)
0.0 (3)
2.3 (105)
10.1 (627)
Hospital compare quality star rating
<.001
2
3.2 (1701)
0.0 (7)
0.0 (0)
26.2 (1132)
9.3 (562)
3
39.7 (21,129)
41.6 (10,576)
31.4 (5474)
48.0 (2073)
49.6 (3006)
4
46.9 (24,979)
50.3 (12,792)
53.8 (9371)
18.5 (798)
33.3 (2018)
5
10.2 (5432)
8.1 (2054)
14.8 (2587)
7.3 (317)
7.8 (474)
Discharges from hospital (total in cohort)
<.001
0–139
1.6 (862)
0.6 (151)
0.9 (166)
1.8 (79)
7.5 (466)
140–616
8.4 (4542)
5.8 (1503)
3.0 (521)
8.6 (389)
34.2 (2129)
617–1622
28.4 (15,343)
30.3 (7823)
28.9 (5054)
14.6 (657)
29.1 (1809)
>1622
61.6 (33,269)
63.3 (16,340)
67.1 (11,734)
75.0 (3377)
29.2 (1818)
Ownership - Hospital
<.001
Government
15.7 (8474)
10.1 (2610)
5.4 (947)
57.3 (2579)
37.6 (2338)
Nonprofit
68.5 (37,016)
74.7 (19,297)
80.2 (14,007)
11.5 (518)
51.3 (3194)
Proprietary
15.8 (8526)
15.1 (3910)
14.4 (2521)
31.2 (1405)
11.1 (690)
Home health agency characteristics
Home health agency location
<.001
Rural
11.4 (6183)
5.7 (1477)
11.0 (1926)
7.2 (324)
39.5 (2456)
Urban
88.6 (47,833)
94.3 (24,340)
89.0 (15,549)
92.8 (4178)
60.5 (3766)
Home health compare quality star rating
<.001
≤ 2.5
7.3 (3938)
4.1 (1046)
9.8 (1701)
5.8 (261)
15.0 (930)
3
13.4 (7193)
9.6 (2455)
14.9 (2600)
7.7 (345)
28.9 (1793)
3.5
19.1 (10,222)
18.9 (4823)
20.9 (3636)
16.4 (737)
16.5 (1026)
4
28.6 (15,325)
25.7 (6548)
39.4 (6856)
18.2 (818)
17.8 (1103)
4.5
23.7 (12,693)
29.6 (7557)
12.3 (2149)
48.3 (2164)
13.3 (823)
5
7.9 (4213)
12.0 (3062)
2.7 (462)
3.5 (159)
8.5 (530)
Number of referrals to home health agencies (total in cohort)
<.001
0–92
2.7 (1444)
1.7 (440)
3.3 (583)
3.3 (150)
4.4 (271)
93–212
7.8 (4236)
3.4 (866)
8.9 (1563)
3.3 (149)
26.6 (1658)
213–471
17.5 (9439)
13.5 (3486)
20.9 (3661)
14.2 (641)
26.5 (1651)
>471
72.0 (38,897)
81.4 (21,025)
66.8 (11,668)
79.1 (3562)
42.5 (2642)
Ownership – Home Health Agencies
<.001
Government
2.3 (1253)
1.1 (277)
2.0 (349)
0.6 (27)
9.7 (600)
Nonprofit
40.3 (21,580)
44.8 (11,427)
37.0 (6433)
31.8 (1428)
36.9 (2292)
Proprietary
57.4 (30,751)
54.1 (13,787)
61.0 (10,622)
67.6 (3029)
53.4 (3313)
All HHC services offered (ie, nursing, physical therapy, occupational therapy, social work, speech therapy, home health aides)
95.9 (51,370)
99.1 (25,257)
92.4 (16,087)
98.6 (4423)
90.3 (5603)
<.001
Values are % (n) unless otherwise noted. P values from Pearson's χ2 test or the Kruskal-Wallis test.
Supplementary Fig. 1Cohort derivation with exclusions. CCN, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Certification Number; CCS, Clinical Classifications Software code; HHA, Home Health Agency; HHC, home health care; NPI, National Provider Identifier.
High prevalence of medication discrepancies between home health referrals and Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services home health certification and plan of care and their potential to affect safety of vulnerable elderly adults.
This work was supported by the Data Science to Patient Value Center at the University of Colorado School of Medicine, United States. Christine Jones is supported by grant number K08HS024569 from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, United States. The Colorado Department of Health Care Policy and Financing, United States provided financial support of the acquisition of the Colorado All Payers Claims Database from the Center for Improving Value in Health Care. The institutions supporting this work had no role in the design or completion of this analysis.
00738-6&id=fx1.jpg){kind=link}